Mammary Glands and Opposable Thumbs
I have boobs. By this I don’t mean I eat too many kebabs, and they grew where they shouldn’t, rather I reached a certain age and there they were, in the right place. That said, I also have thumbs. Thumbs that are not quite satisfied if they are not resting on (or rather wiggling) the little sticky up bits of my PS3 controller, or my Xbox controller, for that matter… or any other games console with buttons I have in the house.
So, yes, I am a woman who likes games. It had never really bothered me before that the industry seems to be seen largely as a man’s world; that the boobed ones are allowed to play in from time to time, until quite recently. The abomination that is Nintendo’s GirlGamer magazine came to my attention while searching the internet for something entirely different, and I think I tasted a bit of sick in my mouth. I won’t go over old ground and repeat why this image is just too ridiculously offensive, however. If you haven’t come across the venom (rightfully) directed at Nintendo, and are unable to work out why it frankly stinks, well, you clearly are neither living in this century nor the last. It did, rather get me to thinking about a lot of other (mis)representations of women in the games industry. Without wishing to go all crazy feminist on you, I’d like to share some of these with you.

Lara Croft shows us her best side.
While doing some academic ‘research’ I came across the story that Lara Croft (it would be illegal to write an article on women and games and not mention Lara Croft) was never meant to have quite such… impressive…? ridiculous…? large…? lady lumps as she ended up with. The story goes that her designer was meant to augment her polygons by a mere 50%, but his finger slipped, and he typed 150% instead. He (and presumably the rest of the men in the office) thought she looked significantly better that way, and so they stuck. I won’t even ask how one manages to type ‘150’, rather than ‘50’, but I am not a programmer, so maybe it wasn’t as simple as all that. This story, (while I admit may be somewhat apocryphal) surely blows the theory out of the water that Lara is a ‘feminist icon.’ I’m not going to sit here and diss Lara, you must understand; I’ve enjoyed playing her games, for the most part, and I’ve been pleased that she is a woman. She is an unrealistic wet dream, but a woman nonetheless.
Another character with a similar physique is Vitalia Domina from the (I won’t hide this fact) incredible Wizardry 8. Vitalia was of the Valkyrie class, but also of the sluttily dressed class. Her armour would not have saved her from anything, unless by some miracle she were stabbed in the bra strap. Her chest rivaled Croft’s. (Hey, they could have had a boob off!) So Sirtech made a relatively likable female. Great! Then ruined it by making her obviously targeted at males. I could go on about women putting their lives at stake by dressing inappropriately. I won’t, though. So don’t worry, you can carry on reading.
What bothers me is the apparent assumption that women want something entirely separate from the gaming industry than men. So I ask the question – what do men want from games? Surely the answer is simple: entertainment. What do women want from games? Um, at a guess; entertainment? As far as I am aware it isn’t a different medium for cookery books, or virtual pets to tickle. I am not saying that these things don’t have their place, the fact that people buy them surely validates their presence, but I do think that there is a lack of traditionally ‘male’ games that are produced with their female audience in mind.
Personally I am not a big fan of war games, I’ll admit. However it isn’t the guns and blood that put me off, it is the slight feeling of uneasiness I get from knowing that while for gamers from the comfort of their lounge it may be fun, for the real soldiers it is real hell. On the other hand, I LOVE blasting the living *insert expletive of choice here* out of aliens with a big Plasma Rifles in Halo, or bagging and tagging the Geth in Mass Effect.

A Geth awaits my Biotic nastiness.
What we do not have, though, is really strong, believable, female leads, who are not merely waiting to be saved, or there for the fun of teenage boys. The Metroid Prime series scores a couple of Brownie points with me, as Samus Aran is at least a woman, but if it weren’t for the eyeshadow that you glimpse when her visor steams up, I am pretty sure you wouldn’t really know. She doesn’t say anything, the armour hides her form, and Samus (unless I am much mistaken) is not a gender specific name.
Mass Effect gives you the option of playing as a woman, which I appreciate. However, all the promo stuff for the game features the default male character. While I can see that keeping continuity is a good idea from a marketing point of view, I think they have missed a trick. If they were to promote a believable female lead (I always play as a woman, and her attitude and bra size are very believable) they may find that they appeal to a wider audience.
There are some developers that realise that producing believable, likable, and suitably attired females is a good idea. I promised myself that I wouldn’t act the fangirl in this article, so I’ll just put two words into your head: Elena Fisher. If you have been in a remote PS3-less cave for a couple of years, and don’t know who she is, Google her. Now.

Elena Fisher: "She's a lot tougher than she looks!"
One great character does not a female gamer satisfy. If it is indeed the case that men and women want the same thing out of their gaming experience, why is it that women get agitated about feeling sidelined? Maybe it is because without decent female characters that make us feel like we were at least in the producers’ minds while they were being designed, we will constantly feel like any units that we buy are merely a bonus for them. Maybe it’s just our time of the month.






Funny that, my gf says I have Moobs.
.
Good article, really insightful.
I agree with the comment about Mass Effect especially, I think Bioware should have done more to show that you can create a main character either as man or woman, and to show the different traits that each character can adopt, regardless of gender. As it stands, every Mass Effect promo has featured the shaved meathead Shephard. Obviously they can’t really change that now, but they could have at least attempted this with Dragon Age.
Thank you for the comments. Your point about the ‘meathead’ Shepherd is also true (and I find it hard to fault much to do with Mass Effect) but yes – my female character (who is NEVER called Jane, by the way) is certainly not a ‘meathead.’ The promo has got it wrong again. It isn’t just a shoot em up, which bulky Commander Jack Shepherd suggests it is.
Having said all that, they clearly are doing something right and getting a great message over, as the sequel is almost certainly going to do fabulously well, like the first.
Best first line EVER!
I’m in love lol
*bows*
I don’t really agree, but well written and well arged Bryony! I think if you presented a game like Mass Effect with a female lead, you would alienate a lot of guys from the game. Games where the lead is solidly female (Tomb Raider, Bayonetta, WET) should obviously be marketed that way, but i think there’s gotta be a balance. maybe i didn’t word that right, but i hope you get what i mean. i think it’s due to a majority male lead over history, so the public consciousness expects to see a male lead, unless the female lead is styalised and created to be very unique. basically i think it’s easier to create bland male heroes that are still attractive from a retail stand point than it is to create female heroines in the same role. ach i’m rambling… good article, welcome to the team!
Thanks. Yes, I get what you mean – despite the ramble!
Possibly the problem is there are actually very few good characters full stop? And it is women that care/notice the most?
Pah. Anyway, I am not a crazy feminist! (Promise.)
Not to offend or alienate women in any way but let’s face it, the only reason most games have male leads is because most gamers are young men, its black and white, simple. But I understand what Bryony’s point is that on that rare occasion when a game has a female protagonist, she’s usually portrayed in a shallow manner. Which again is simply because the devs are targeting young males. In my opinion its nothing to do with being sexist, its all about the money and big boobs sell.
Nice, controversial read.
I agree with most of what you say; I don’t necessarily think sexism is what drives this, but I do think that the devs are missing out if they don’t think that women game that much. Clearly we do.
My real issue is that while I enjoy a wide(ish) variery of games, I feel like I wasn’t really in the mind of the people making it. I’d like to feel more appreciated as a consumer, and not that I am just playing with boys toys.
Okay, think I understand you a bit more now. You want to see more female characters like Elena Fisher in video games (even if they’re not leads?). But considering very few games have a good narrative like Uncharted 2 apparently does, do you think that devs will bother making characters with depth and realism? I’m not being sarcastic, I wanna know what you think.
Maybe we need more games with great story lines, then? I kind of take your point, though. But, on the other hand, was Uncharted 2 really that great a STORY? I mean, I cared about what happened, (during the village seige scene I was genuinely upset and punched almost every one to death) but maybe I cared because I like Nate and Elena?
If you take out Nate and Elena (and Sully, Tenzin and the rest for that matter) and replace them with more one dimensional generic characters, would it have been the same? A great romp, maybe, but I doubt I would’ve been that bothered by what was going to happen, or how Nathan was going to choose between the two ladies.
And – yes to your first question, by the way. I for one would love to see a game with Elena as the playable character, and maybe Nathan as an NPC.
i agree. also, there are very few positive black male leads in games. all the ones i can think of are either criminals or guys who used to be criminals. i understand that, considering some of the places these games are set, it’s a result of attempted realism, but i think black males feel much the same way as females do about game lead characters a lot of the time. my mate at college really liked Mass Effect because it let him make his character a black character. then again, he did say it still wasn’t right because Shephard’s voice is decidedly strong and white, but never mind. god i ramble sometimes…
Very good point. It seems that the games industry has kind of missed the whole idea of widening their appeal by including people from all sections of society, nnot just race and gender, but all sorts.
Actually, this is one (THE one) irritation I have with Uncharted – the baddies have non-American accents, even SPOILER SPOILER SPOILER Harry Flynn. END SPOILER.
That doesn’t bother me as much I actually thought it would. For me its more about story and how believable the character is. His/Her race is secondary. Being black myself, of course it’d be nice to see more black leads in games and even nicer if they weren’t all stereotypes.
But going back to the people that make the games, most of them are (presumably) white males. So the default race and gender for most of the leads would be…white males. It doesn’t make me bitter honestly, its just the way it is.
More important than any of that stuff…
She wrote boobs!
Teeheehee
Great article, I agree with everything you said. I think Elena would make a pretty good playable character as long as the game was set up right. I think the reason games still have a majority of male leads is because its easier to write a sarcastic, muscled up, butch male lead than a female lead, who usually tend to either be a bit on the overly aggressive (and sweary) side or are quiet and mysterious (before they shoot your head off)this leads to them being a bit more challenging to market.. not everyone likes a sweary female and the same can be said for the latter. I think the current games aimed at girls in the market are very short-sighted given that a recent survey in the US found that 45% of ‘active gamers’ were female. However with games like ‘WET’ and Bayonetta which is fast approaching (although she is very much aimed at a male audience image wise) I would hope that there is potential for a continuous stream of good female characters in the future.
Thanks Tasha. I, for one, do not like sweary people (be they male or female) although I do like the idea of your example of the ‘quiet and mysterious (before they shoot your head off.)’ THAT I can get on board with… Anyway, There is obvioulsy a need for forward thinking writers out there, who better understand the changing market.
It isn’t just about the characters, although that is a large part of it. I don’t mind seeing guys in games (in some cases I actively enjoy it) but I do like to feel like I am not sneakily playing with boys toys while they are away doing something else.
I myself like both types of characters (sweary i find quite funny). For me when I start playing a game I want to connect to the characters (regardless of gender) and the story, if I don’t like the main character or the story I tend to lose interest very quickly no matter how great the gameplay is (fallout 3 being an example) if I can’t be immersed and sucked in by the characters and their story I find the game pointless (with exceptions of sports games obviously). I agree with the boy toys thing, whenever I say I like Uncharted, Borderlands, GTA etc I immediately get a look that is a kind of: ‘but you’re a girl’ look. I think it’s up to good writers to produce a game that changes the stereotypes in games but games isnt the only media that is guilty of it (movies, tv have the same kind of stereotypes) meaning the social norm tends to be: girl in distress, man saves girl or girls an idiot/cant handle herself, man has to drag woman along for the ride because shes a stubborn mare. I think the change would have to occur across the media platforms for the general opinion on girls and games to change.
For anyone interested – there is this going on http://womeningames.com/
Hey now that looks like fun. And right up my street. I wonder if I could get TIMJ to pay mmy expenses… it *would* make a lovely birthday present.
Seriously, though, thank you for that link.